Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Be dissolved. I think sanctions and making Israel economically unviable are a peaceful solution.




What makes you think "dissolving Israel" would be any more peaceful than "dissolving Gaza" would be?

Israel need US protection and money. If you take that away, the settlers go home. If they don't, then yes, I'm sure the US can defeat Israel in armed conflict.

[flagged]


I think Americans are done hearing about Zionist invented fictional scenarios. The reality is that Palestine has been ethnically cleansed by Zionists. The other reality is that young Americans see Israel as our enemy, so there will be no support in the near future.

The only fictional scenario here is the one you're proposing where you think you can ethnically cleanse 10 million Israelis without any consequence.

[flagged]


[flagged]


Returning Palestinian land to Palestinians isn’t “ethnic cleansing”. It’s righting a brutal crime against humanity. It’s 100% on Zionists for creating this situation.

[flagged]


That’s rich considering Zionists are using very nebulous, 2,000 year old lore to justify their occupation.

[flagged]


This is all on the Zionists to resolve. They created this situation and owe it to the world to clean it up. I don’t see anything wrong with Europe taking in the Zionists. It’s literally the birthplace of Zionism.

[flagged]


Palestinians, regardless of their religion, need their land returned to them.

[flagged]


They can return to their countries of origin or face military repercussions.

And what is your proposal for those with no other country of origin - either because they were born in Israel, were ethnically cleansed by their previous country, or their previous country no longer exists?

Europe owes the world reparations for Zionism, so they can house these people.

You might as well say the Arab states owe the world reparations for ethnically cleansing Mizrahi Jews, so they can house the Palestinians.

My president isn’t running interference for Arab ethnic cleansing using my tax dollars. They owe me nothing.

You said this in response to my post pointing out the majority were expelled from Arab lands. You're telling them to go back and die.

They have a lot of reparations to make to their neighbors (and the entire planet).

Making Israel unviable is condemning the Jews to death. You think that's a proper solution?

And don't say "go home". The majority are descended from those expelled from Arab lands, there's no home to go to.


Did Apartheid South Africa becoming unviable condemned white south africans to death?

Did the blacks promise genocide of the whites in South Africa? No.

Do the Palestinians promise genocide of the Jews in Israel? Yes.


Is this a trick question?

The answer is no. They still get to live there.

This is pure histrionics. It’s the Zionists committing genocide, today. Today’s reality trumps tomorrow’s fictional scenario.

Your comment is as extreme as Israel's actions at the moment.

This sort of mentality will perpetuate conflict and atrocities.


No, my comment reflects how the vast majority of people on this planet think. Israel will be the next Rhodesia.

[flagged]


I’m not Muslim nor in Hamas. I’m speaking as an American who wants a total removal of Zionist influence from my government based on Zionist actions both in Palestine and the US.

Are there not "Jewish only" roads and areas in the occupied West Bank? Do Jewish Israelis not use "From the river to the sea" as well? Is Israel not attacking several different countries in the region? Let me guess, that's different.

> Are there not "Jewish only" roads and areas in the occupied West Bank

Not really, there are security measures connected to citizenship and vehicle registration, not "Jewish only" roads. Jews are not allowed in Area A, though.

> Is Israel not attacking several different countries in the region?

Not really, it responded to several attacks against it. Do you expect Israel to tolerate attacks with no response? States that gave up on trying to destroy Israel, like Egypt and Jordan, have not been attacked by Israel since.

> Do Jewish Israelis not use "From the river to the sea" as well?

"Between the sea and the Jordan there will only be Israeli sovereignty" is not nearly as problematic as "From the river to the sea, Palestine will be Arab".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: