Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You need roads anyway! Most of the businesses need to get trucks in to deliver the things they need. Thus you can reuse those roads for buses for places that are less busy and this is cheaper than a train. The real trick is how to get private one passenger automobiles off the roads.

In very dense areas you should have both roads and trains. However only the most dense cities in the world can support that, and then only in their most dense which is often small. For everyone else buses save money over trains.



But buses actually don’t. you just pay for it later. Roads are one of the fastest deteriorating forms of infrastructure. the hole “ but rail dosnt make money” argument ignores the fact that… roads don’t ether


The time frame before a rail line will save money over buses is measured in decades.

With buses, you don't include the cost of road maintenance because buses share the roads with millions of other vehicles so the allocable cost is neglible.


Extept that you have to maintain the roads anyway. taking a few buses off won't save much so long as the road for trucks exists.


Most European cities are transitioning towards dedicated bus lanes. In that case, in principle, that can be light rail or tram too. The biggest problem is crossing with normal roads. Trams are more tricky to implement than busses.


Roads for buses and trucks are far more expensive than for cars. Car drivers are absolutely subsidizing bus passengers by order of magnitude. Per passenger mile even Uber is cheaper.


Not when car volume is several orders of magnitude higher than bus volume. Bus passengers are subsidizing car drivers.


Busses and trucks damage roads up to 30,000 (yes 30k) more than cars. Cars absolutely subsidise all roads.

And btw neither buses nor trucks nor cars have some constitutional right of way.


A one lane road with minimal parking can handle a crazy number of deliveries and busses. Allow cars on that road and suddenly it’s almost useless as a transportation option.

Thus the urban infrastructure dilemma.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: