Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It can't really "gobble" anything any more than a star "gobbles" things that fly into its photosphere or a planet "gobbles" things that crash into it.

Unless you cross its event horizon, its gravity works just like any other celestial object. Maybe at worst it slingshots you off in a different direction.



I think the concern is that if a star was headed in our direction we’d see it coming. We don’t see one, so we know there is no anticipated threat.

A small, lone black hole could be on an intersecting trajectory with us within a few years and we’d be completely oblivious.


If I was going to be afraid of an invisible killer, I would be far more concerned with gamma-ray bursts. It covers a much larger area than that a black hole and could crisp our planet like some kind of sci-fi intergalactic superweapon laser beam. And some might consider getting turned to ash in mere moments a mercy compared to the potential of a near "miss" that would give half the planet instant cancer and completely fuck our weather patterns beyond any comprehension.

Still not super likely, but I would think far more likely than a direct hit by a black hole.


A mass of 6x to 7x our sun (size of this object) would start messing with solar system orbits well before it got here. Not that that would be much better for us!


Yeah it wouldn't just sneak up on us. We would have years and years to worry and hypothesize before finally just dying.


Barely enough time to recruit a bunch of lovably gruff leatherneck astronauts to drill a hole in it and blow it up with a nuclear bomb.


Wouldn't it be quicker to train some drilling experts how to be astronauts though?


> finally just dying

Is this what would happen if we got slurped into a black hole? I was hoping for something more exciting …


We would most likely freeze to death. As the black hole crossed the asteroid belt we would be pulled away from the sun as it started to compete with the black hole's gravity. Depending how fast the black hole was moving we might die over a few months or we might freeze to death in a few days. Probably there are paths where the earth would briefly be pulled into an elliptical orbit, and then we would be burnt to a crisp as we circled back close to the sun.


This is the setting of one of my favorite short stories, A Pail Full of Air.

Which I am delighted to note, since the last time I referenced it, appears to have fallen out of copyright, so I can link straight to it on Project Gutenberg: https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/51461/pg51461.txt


In a chaos such as that we would get killed by the weather before we even realized what was happening.


I thought you ended up behind a bookshelf.


Well, we hit a little snag when the universe sort of collapsed on itself. But dad seemed cautiously optimistic.


It seems hard to see a way that life forms survive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaghettification.


As if there were any different actions that could be taken to avoid a star vs a black hole.

I’d probably welcome the quicker demise tbh


It’s less about actions we could take and more about knowing we don’t have to worry about colliding with a star for the moment.


You probably wouldn’t want society to know we were about to collide with a star-sized mass, visible or not.


> wouldn’t want society to know we were about to collide with a star-sized mass

I may be misunderstanding the distances involved but wouldn't such a collision take centuries if not thousands of years to play out? For the most part it would just look like we had 2 suns, one of which gets a few millimeters bigger (to the naked eye) every year.


Yes, and the weather would ruin us long before any exciting cosmological collision took place.


ah dammit I didn't think of that you're right it would be more of a disturbed orbit, weird ass days and nights but hey atleast there's a chance the scientists could have close up real life simulation of the three body problem


We’d see the lensing soon enough, but couldn’t do anything about it


Fortunately space is really, really, really, really, really, really, REALLY big. The chance of this happening is so infinitesimal we might as well worry about spontaneously transforming into a whale or potted flower manifested a mile above the surface of our planet.


If the result were both the same as well as inevitable, does it really matter whether you saw it coming?


I wonder if a few solar mass black hole would bend light far enough around it that it would show up at some point.

With all that said, maybe it's better off if we were completely oblivious.


I wonder what the chances are if there's a few of them within the Boötes void. It's pretty big.


> maybe it's better off if we were completely oblivious.

even that would be a slow death I suppose. Don’t think the Earth would just vanish instantly.


I'd wager such an encounter is way more likely to result in any of:

1) the Earth being flung out of the Sun's orbit

2) planetary orbits becoming disrupted such that an encounter with another planet over the coming years or millennia becomes likely,

2.1) which could eventually have the same "flinging away from the Sun" effect,

2.2) or (unlikely, but possible) result in a collision

2.3) or result in the Earth being shredded into asteroids

2.4) or other planets suffering that fate and then showering the Earth with dangerously-large asteroids over a period of decades or centuries until it's nearly, or actually (think: outright crust liquefaction from impacts) lifeless.

than the Earth actually getting swallowed up, by at least an order of magnitude.

IOW, the most-likely "we're all dead" outcomes for us, from a close encounter with a massive rogue anything really, including a black hole, might take years and years to play out.


Sounds like a plot of Seveneves by Neal Stephenson


Schwarzschild radius of a 10 stellar mass black hole is ~20 miles. It would need to be pretty close in order to resolve optically.


Yet they detected a lone black hole in the article. Maybe detection isn't guaranteed though?


Detection typically requires exceptionally rare circumstances - which if looking at a dataset the size of the visible universe, typically turns up several examples if we look hard enough.

But any specific random example, is often brutally hard to see.


If we saw a star coming toward us...

Have you seen the Walking Dead?


No, how does that relate?


I'm pretty sure it would be something like even if a star was coming and we saw it what the fuck could we even do it would just create mass panic, hysteria and would make everyone hella religious depending on how early we detect it though we might have some time to make good memories before we die. atleast I would prefer a black hole smashing into us unbeknownst to us instead of a known star. Also no one would want to show up to jobs and stuff



That brings me memories of Cosmos 1999. The moon left Earth's orbit to outer space because explosions, but being slingshoted away because a nearby massive enough object passing by looks like a more possible scenario, not explored enough by sci-fi.


The basic premise of the show that an explosion at a nuclear waste dump could produce enough energy to push the Moon out of the Solar System to wander the galaxy is an interesting product of its time. Concerns over the power of nuclear explosions was high and casual access to knowledge about the plausibility of such a scenario was somewhat limited.

There's a fan driven update called Space: 2099 that improves some of the more dated aspects of the show, including showing the Moon enter some type of portal or wormhole to make suspension of disbelief easier. While the Special Edition releases of Star Wars often suffered from updating certain aspects, especially special effects, the Space: 2099 changes were generally good for the show. Too bad they're unable to fund raise enough and get permission to do the entire series.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wPTZaSv9Bxk


Arguably, the information was there. People just chose to be ignorant.


> Cosmos 1999

Space: 1999. Do you happen to be french or polish?

In Germany they called it "Mondbasis Alpha". As I child I really liked this series and it's predecessor UFO made by the same team (Gerry and Sylvia Anderson of Thunderbirds fame).


He technically did not say the invisible monster was a black hole.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: