I'm pretty sure you didn't read or take seriously his post. He pointed out specific reasons why water wasn't relevant and that the suggested method didn't scale. Please reconsider and edit your post as your tone is far more problematic.
I've flagged this comment for two reasons: Your tone is unnecessarily hostile, and you haven't provided any additional information. This is pure flamewar material (and may actually mark the first time I've seen a flamewar about offline flames!); please consider a more constructive approach to the conversation.