Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Nice idea, however I'd hope that modern radar is able to detect two aircraft of that size flying close together.

Unless the perpetrators know the various limitations of each radar installation?



Civilian flight control and radar is designed and optimized for a fully cooperative system, extremely so. It's not designed for filtering through data to track down inconsistencies and identify potential bad actors, it's not a military air defense system.


From what I understand, the traces they are correlating now come from military radar (which is also why they have not been made public).


Maybe, but would the operators have the imagination to suspect it was something other than a glitch?


It's likely that this could be detected by looking at recorded radar-data as a above-average number of "glitches" at this particular track.

But then, I also assume that modern radar systems have some way to automatically filter displayed tracks for "glitches" or temporary loss of contact to a airplane signal to avoid distracting or tiring out airspace controllers.


Hindsight is a wondrous thing eh?


It's a matter of radar resolution. Radars can't distinguish flies apart from each other, so obviously there are technology limitations anyway.


It is indeed, in the 40's they had this issue, when planes were a ~mile apart they become a mush on the screen.

However thats not the case nowadays. Even if you had a nasty radar from the 80's you see that the trace is twice the size it should be. (We'll I'd hope)

I'd assume that military radar ops would be looking for this, as this is a great way to sneak assets about.


From what I read elsewhere, synchronization problems between different radar systems and other effects can also cause echoes or "ghosting" to appear, so it's not uncommon to see more than one trace for a particular object. Depending on the sophistication of the radar system, these traces could be ignored either by software or by operators.

When they say they put national security second to investigating the flight, what they're saying is that they're now exposing a lot of information about these radar systems with other countries in order to figure out what happened.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: