Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Forgive the crudeness of the example, but there's a huge difference between the following two sentences:

I had to help my uncle Jack off a horse.

i had to help my uncle jack off a horse.



I suspect a reduction in the number of people with names like that, much like Dick, Gaylord, etc.


i had to help my uncle, jack, off a horse.


And that doesn't "read" well.


I agree. It's how I type when I don't care or not putting in as much effort - like feeling lazy or perhaps unmotivated or depressed.


It reads well to me.


I don't think you would choose to use this particular sentence in a serious communication with anyone. The letter case would just not be enough of a distinguishing factor for you to risk the wrong meaning being conveyed. The letter case only has a very small meaning once you get used to using small caps.


"Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_buffalo_Buffalo_buffalo...


All languages change and have ambiguities. Modern English (with Capital Letters) has lots of ambiguities that cannot be disambiguated with capitals (e.g. "a small girls school")


So? Capital letters obviate one class of ambiguities. That there are classes of ambiguity they do not is not a reason to not use them.


Conversely, on its own, the fact that they remove some ambiguities is not a sufficient reason to use them.

Since the downvoters disagree, I'll provide a proof.

1. Suppose resolution of ambiguities is a sufficient reason for a separate case in written language.

2. Ambiguities exist that are not resolved.

3. New cases are not created to resolve these.

4. By contradiction, 1 is false.

QED

There may be other reasons which in addition to the resolution of ambiguity are sufficient to justify case, but you can't simply cite the resolution of ambiguity and say conclude that case is justified.


No language is perfectly unambiguous, but language evolution should trend toward clarity, not away from it.


Or, a language should tend toward simplicity, without unnecessary frills. Which you'd prefer is probably just taste.


to add - the main meaning of upper case is to help separate sentences, because the dot alone is not enough, unless the reader is specifically used for the dot to be the only separator. this is an example.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: