Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's marked as an ad the exact same way they do it on Android and the exact same way it's done on Google.

These responses are a bit surprising. I wonder how people would have responded if this were about Android.





> I wonder how people would have responded if this were about Android.

As someone who uses both Android and iOS (the dual usage being in large part because I develop software for both) if this were about Android I wouldn't be surprised in the least, but I do find it surprising for Apple to increasingly allow for this sort of thing.

IMO the major positive differentiators Apple has over Google as a phone OS provider are the perception of protecting user privacy and also not plastering ads everywhere. This example weakens both of those perceptions at the same time.

So (for me) its not about Apple being worse than Google when it comes to this stuff, its just surprising they are willing to be as bad.

In any case, I don't have a horse in the race to cheer for. Google's major positive differentiator has been flexibility for advanced users to run what they want with minimal OS interference, and Google has been tamping down on that, so from my perspective both appear to be destroying their previous benefits to meet somewhere in the worst-case (for end users) middle.


> It's marked as an ad the exact same way they do it on Android and the exact same way it's done on Google.

That is, in the most deceiving way they could think of while still being able to say they marked it.


It's really not that deceptive. It says "Ad", right there. I can think of about 40 different, more deceptive ways they could have gone. If that was their goal... they failed.

I think the comments are in the context of the top level comment which says:

> One of the differentiators between iOS and Google was a lack of ads

> Increasing ads, or having them at all, really erodes the user experience

> Apple managed to become the most valuable company in the world without ads




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: