Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

For me the worst of this is organizations where employees have to write their own performance reviews. Eff that. You're the boss, you tell me how I'm doing. If there's one thing a manager should be accountable for it is the development and evaluation of the people the manager is responsible for.




No - Performance reviews are important legally, it's the only company IP you're entitled to take with you when you leave etc, so this is where you can have evidence of specific projects etc.

Also - If you write the PR you want to get and give to your manager, the burden of effort falls on the manager to correct it where they disagree. If your manager writes it, the burden of effort falls on the manager to comprehensively justify your value as a matter of record. It is better the former be halfassed than the latter


> Performance reviews are (...) the only company IP you're entitled to take with you when you leave etc, so this is where you can have evidence of specific projects etc.

Wait what? I never heard about this in nearly two decades of working. Is this jurisdiction specific or a general case?

You'd think this would be no. 1 thing advice given to new joiners, or given by career couches, or given in all these threads where people ask how to deal with "Github history as proof of work" when you worked on proprietary code for years.

> If you write the PR you want to get and give to your manager, the burden of effort falls on the manager to correct it where they disagree. If your manager writes it, the burden of effort falls on the manager to comprehensively justify your value as a matter of record. It is better the former be halfassed than the latter

That is a good point to keep in mind, I agree.


> Wait what? I never heard about this in nearly two decades of working. Is this jurisdiction specific or a general case?

It was a surprise to me too!!! I heard this from my employment attorney in Massachusetts USA.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: