Teams I have worked in often have an Approved subject to comments” with th “all comments must be resolved” marker set.
This somewhat violates the articles “approval or not is the only bit that matters” argument, but it at least forces participants to at least acknowledge an issue, and either provide a satisfactory reason to resolve on the spot, or open a new ticket for that work.
That was addressed by someone else: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45705759 . Also that just sounds like comments with extra steps. What is the meaning of plain comments in these teams?
This somewhat violates the articles “approval or not is the only bit that matters” argument, but it at least forces participants to at least acknowledge an issue, and either provide a satisfactory reason to resolve on the spot, or open a new ticket for that work.