Right, luxury items are definitely an apt analogy here. Man, people really do love to argue, huh.

The point is that business decisions aren't magically correct. People can, and do, open stores in oversaturated markets. When your cupcake shop flops, that's sad; when hospitals close, that can be devastating to a community. It makes at least theoretical sense for states to try and prevent that impact.

Avoid the impact from hospital closures by preventing them from opening in the first place? Hospital closures are devastating if they're the only one in the area, or remaining facilities don't have enough slack. They aren't devastating in an oversaturated market.

> Avoid the impact from hospital closures by preventing them from opening in the first place?

Yes? That's the idea. I won't say it always works, but it's the idea; preventing the existing facilities from closing.

> They aren't devastating in an oversaturated market.

It certainly can be, if the oversaturation puts all of them on shaky financial grounds.