Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I spent yesterday afternoon doing this. It go to the point where it would acknowledge it was wrong, but would keep giving me the same answer.

It also said it would only try one more time before giving up, but then kept going.



The worst is when it can't do something right, and it does a horrible mock/hack to get it "working." I had a claude fake benchmark data, that pissed me off a bit, though I did make a major architectural improvement to a tool as result (though the real benchmark would have probably made me do it anyhow) so it wasn't all horrible.


this happens to me constantly, it's such a huge waste of time. I'm not convinced any of these tools actually save time. It's all a fucking slot machine and Gell-Mann Amnesia and at the end, you often have nothing that works.

I spent like two hours yesterday dicking with aider to make a one line change and it hallucinated an invalid input for the only possible parameter and I wound up using the docs the old fashioned way and doing the task in about two minutes


The mistake was using AI for a two minute fix. It totally helps at some tasks. Takes some failures to realize that it does indeed have flaws.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: