Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Being embarrassed by your nationality or citizenship is certainly a feat of small mindedness.


Plenty of big thinkers out there think nations and citizenship are outmoded concepts, or they are concepts that provoke needless violence. They find their own nationalities an embarrassment.


> Plenty of big thinkers out there think nations and citizenship are outmoded concepts.

Big thinkers tend to live in wealthy, leafy areas where they don't have to worry about someone jumping over their fence, or appreciate the need for demarcation of land.

Same goes for people who are pro-immigration/pro-drugs/pro-construction - but just don't do it their affluent area.


I've been to plenty of Food Not Bombs events where people are being fed and the prevailing attitude was, "If there are people needing to be fed, let them come and we'll feed them." The same folks were handing out harm reduction supplies.

These same folks went on to figure out the logistics of preparing food. So no, I don't think it's at all axiomatic that the people who disagree with nationalism are necessarily affluent in the slightest. In fact, I've found most solidarity with refugees and anti-nationalist movements in the working class. The overall community of folks I saw ranged across income brackets -- plenty of software engineers, tech folks, trades folks, unemployed folks...

I think that when people say, "They don't really mean it" or "their principles wouldn't stand up if it meant a disruption to their lives", they are not aware of just how much work folks are actively doing every day to live by those principles and invite people in.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: