Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

All it did was prove to Iran they need nuclear weapons. There’s one thing every country knows and it’s that the only way you don’t become the target of Russia, the US, or Israel is to maintain a nuclear arsenal.

We couldn’t stop North Korea with threats of violence but we did manage to stop Iran for almost 50 years through diplomacy. That’s all pissed down the drain now.






This.

Ukraine gave up its nukes to Russia after the collapse of the USSR with a treaty-promise that Russia will never be an aggressor.

Iran has now been bombed into regime change for trying to even get to that point.

If there's one thing every 2-bit aspiring dictator now knows, it's the only way to protect yourself is to get nukes.

This wasn't a non-proliferation enforcement action, this was the nail in the coffin of all future non-proliferation efforts.


Also: Khadafy. We asked him to not pursue nukes (and for whatever reason he didn't). When there was unrest in his country the European powers (first) and the US (later) struck him. They would have never done that if he had a nuke.

Now we have regime change and Libya is a paradise. /s

One of the problems with all of this is we may hate the government, but in getting rid of it we don't get anything better.


This needs to be repeated over and over every time it comes up:

North Korea is poised to level Seoul with conventional rocket artillery. A military solution has never been an option. Threats of violence in Korea are transparent.


Iran has killed, threatened, or killed-through-proxy many Americans in the last 50 years. They have created and sown instability throughout the region threatening Israel, Iraq, and Saudi Arabia just to name a few. Notice that none of their regional neighbors have come to their defense.

They have consistently and openly threatened US leaders.

There was no diplomacy here.


What a bunch of assholes, you're right, there's no talking to them. I wonder why they're so angry at us?

"The last 50 years", you say? Oh, so right around the time when the US and Britain overthrew Iran's democratically elected Prime Minister to install a religious nutcase, because that nutcase would agree to sell them oil at a better price?

No, can't imagine that causing any bitterness.

We reaped what we sowed with Iran.


>"The last 50 years", you say? Oh, so right around the time when the US and Britain overthrew Iran's democratically elected Prime Minister to install a religious nutcase, because that nutcase would agree to sell them oil at a better price?

When people are mixing up basic facts like this you know the mainstream's knowledge of Iran is heavily propagandized. Really would help if people actually read a history textbook for once instead of believing everything they hear from someone else.


There are many countries who easily avoid becoming the target of Russia, the US, or Israel without maintaining a nuclear arsenal…

Stuxnet and the constant assassinations of scientists is diplomacy?

Oh we stopped them? They’ve steadily advanced towards being a nuclear state regardless of all the diplomacy deployed. How many countries don’t have nukes that aren’t being invaded. Canada, Italy, Japan, Costa Rica etc. they don’t have nukes and I don’t think they’re about to be invaded because they’ve joined the international community and are not sponsoring hezbollah or houthis etc.

>Oh we stopped them? They’ve steadily advanced towards being a nuclear state regardless of all the diplomacy deployed.

Yes, we stopped them. How many nuclear weapons does Iran possess today? 0? Despite having a vast, VAST head start on North Korea - like decades worth of experience and capabilities. The ONLY reason they don't have one today is the diplomacy that convinced them to not move forward faster.

>How many countries don’t have nukes that aren’t being invaded. Canada, Italy, Japan, Costa Rica etc.

I think my favorite part is when the first country on your list is one who has been threatened repeatedly by the current US administration.

What exactly do you think Canada is going to do should Trump decide to follow-through on his threats of making them the 51st state? Make some strongly worded notices of condemnation with the UN while Ottawa is being razed?

Costa Rica has nothing anybody wants. If the US tomorrow declared they are no longer protecting Japan, they would likley find themselves invaded by Japan before the end of the year. The only reason Italy is safe is because they're part of the EU, and the EU has... you guessed it... access to nuclear weapons.


Ok the assumptions in this thread are now officially out of hand

> The ONLY reason they don't have one today is the diplomacy that convinced them to not move forward faster.

Yet, if they had moved faster, force would've been used to stop them earlier.


Israel has been using force for multiple decades to no avail, it ultimately was delayed by diplomacy.

If force alone could stop a nuclear program, why does North Korea have bombs? Many nations could have attacked them without any concerns of recourse for decades.


Maybe the US and Europeans should stop meddling in the middle east if they don't want to be their enemies

Is the EU meddling? I though it was U.S. and Israël that were the driving force of those crusades.

Iraqi invesion was aminly driven by US, UK and Poland, but some countries was involed too(i.e. Ukraine for some reason)

Mostly UK, less so in recent years though.



Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: