Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


> After the uutils debacle

Which debacle?


[flagged]


So what I’m getting is

1. The uutils project didn’t also make all locales cases for sort faster even though the majority of people will be using UTF-8, C or POSIX where it is indeed faster

2. There’s a lot of debating about different test cases which is a never ending quibble with sorting routines (go look at some of the cutting edge sort algorithm development).

This complaint is hyperfocusing on 1 of the many utilities they claim they’re faster on and quibbling about what to me are important but ultimately minor critiques. I really don’t see the debacle.

As for the license, that’s more your opinion. Rust as a language generally has dual licensed their code as MIT and Apache2 and most open source projects follow this tradition. I don’t see the conspiracy that you do. And just so I’m clear, the corporation your criticizing here as the amorphous evil entity funding this is Ubuntu right?


>1. The uutils project didn’t also make all locales cases for sort faster even though the majority of people will be using UTF-8, C or POSIX where it is indeed faster

locale != encoding.

Try sort a phone book with tr_TR.UTF-8 vs en_US.UTF-8


I know. UTF-8, C and POSIX are locales (at least those are the locale strings)


So what was I supposed to get from that 4chan wannabe site? That the project is not currently at fast as GNU? Where is the lying?


You should of course verify these results in your scenario. However, I somewhat doubt that the person exists who cares greatly about performance, and is still willing to consider bzip2. There isn't a point anywhere in the design space where bzip2 beats zstd. You can get smaller outputs from zstd in 1/20th the time for many common inputs, or you can spend the same amount of time and get a significantly smaller output, and zstd decompression is again 20-50x faster depending. So the speed of your bzip2 implementation hardly seems worth arguing over.


Sure there is: someone provided you bzip2 files. Or required you give them files in that format.

Then you don’t have a choice.

And if you have to use it, 14% is a really nice speed up.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: