Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Imagine if Elon had put all that money to work on mass transit solutions instead of cars for each and every person, along with tunnels for those cars. Of course, you will never make the same riches, but interesting to imagine how different the impact might be.



Both of these companies contributed approximately nothing to the advancement of Mass Transit.


Arguably the Hyperloop was publicized specifically for the opposite: to stoke opposition to traditional high speed rail, while at the same time knowing it is completely impractical.



This is just tiny foil hat thinking though. It seems far more likto me that Elon was just a trifle overconfident in himself.


OK, so Elon has tried to invest a lot of money in mass transit, but wasn't able to get a breakthrough like he did with Tesla?


Why rely on one man?


The goal is not to rely on one man, but regardless of what you think of him, he has proven to be very effective at bringing big ideas to reality.


> very effective at bringing big ideas to reality

With specific reference to Mr Musk and commuter rail, this is the opposite of reality. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44297667


Maybe the OP is taking about some other Musk's ideas brought to reality, like fascism in the US.


True, but I don't regard that as an original Musk idea. It's been done before elsewhere and, to a lesser extent, done before in the US. He's not even the first racist head of a US car company, that was Henry Ford.


Ah-hahahahahaha.

Good one.

This message was not written from my hyperloop commute to Mars.


Sure, but who do you know who actually built a functioning rocket launch company privately AND also built a leading EV company when it was unheard of?

I agree that he also has stupid, botched ideas, but pretending like he’s incompetent is just cope.


No point in imagining that whatsoever. Just like imagining Bezos paying taxes or Trump not lying.


Or like imagining people on the internet not make everything about American politics




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: