Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's just software running on a server...this isn't a Johnny Depp movie [1]. Just flip the power switch on the racks.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0jg3mSf561w



Rather, it’s many different types of software running on many different systems around the world, each funded by a different party with its own motives. This is no movie…


True, but the system only exists because it is currently economically viable. A mass taboo against AI would change that. And many people outside of tech already dislike AI a lot, so it's not inconceivable that this dislike could be fuelled into a worldwide taboo.


> True, but the system only exists because it is currently economically viable.

The "system" isn't a thing, but more like running apps, some run on servers, other consumer hardware. And the parts that run on consumer hardware will be around even if 99% of the current hyped up ecosystem dies overnight, people won't suddenly stop trying to run these things locally.


And every single one has a power switch.

I get the general "too many variables" argument, but the idea that humans have no means of stopping any of these apps/systems/algorithms/etc if they get "out of control" (a farce in itself as it's a chat bot) is ridiculous.

It's very interesting to see how badly people want to be living in and being an active participant in a sci-fi flick. I think that's far more concerning than the AI itself.


Hmm, good point. Also, when COVID struck, although it took some time, everyone collectively participated in staying home (more or less, I know some people didn't but the participating was vast). We can do the same if we choose.


"Skynet was software; in cyberspace. There was no system core; it could not be shut down"

Yes. Look at how much trouble we have now with distributed denial of service attacks.

Go re-read "Daemon" and "Freedom™", by Daniel Suarez (2006). That AI is dumber than what we have now.


On the other hand, if those fighting Skynet were asked to trade Skynet for the AI we have now, they would take it as their new enemy in a heartbeat.


Eh, it's exactly the Johnny Depp movie that would simplify this into "just flip the power switch".

LLM code already runs on millions of servers and other devices, across thousands of racks, hundreds of data centers, distributed across the globe under dozens of different governments, etc. The open source models are globally distributed and impossible to delete. The underlying math is public domain for anyone to read.


Sure, but those millions of servers and devices are not directly connected (nor can be by the AI). The plot in the movie I shared necessitated the AI being able to turn any computer into extra compute for itself—what's necessary for a "we can never shut it down" scenario.

The power switch is still king, even if it's millions of power switches versus one.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: