Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> At the same time, Microsoft will likely replicate Windsurf and Cursor's features within a year. And deliver them with far greater stability and polish.

I agree with the first part, I'm much less optimistic about the second part. I suspect they will create something that is worse, but cheaper if you already pay for Github/Office 365/whatever. Then many large enterprises will switch to save money whilst the engineers complain, just like with Teams.



They already succeedd well enough that VSCode is the only Electron app I tolerate on my private systems, naturally on device assigned ones I have less control.


I mean they already have. GitHub Copilot was the first LLM coding tool before "LLM" was in the lexicon. MS/Github kind of squandered their lead with it, but they released Agent Mode a few months back https://github.blog/news-insights/product-news/github-copilo...


That seems pretty bold. I still find myself switching to basically anything but the VS code copilot agent any chance I get.


Can you expand on that? What's so bad about VSC's copilot agent? What do you switch to?


If the VS Code team are delivering the product, I have some amount of trust. If it’s the VS team, good luck to everyone involved


I use vscode for personal javascript projects but the time I spent on a .NET team using VS was an incredible downgrade compared to years and years of intellij. I ended up leaving because tech debt/bugs kept causing weekly overnight on call incidents that we were never given time to fix, but when they asked who wanted a Rider license I got myself on the list immediately.


Indeed, Copilot within Visual Studio is nowhere close as good as Copilot within VSCode, and even that is still worse than Cursor in my experience.


VSCode is still miles behind for .NET and C++ tooling, have a bit of fate on VS team.


What’s the use of being miles ahead if you’re traveling in the wrong direction?


Doesn't look like, given Windows market share.


Not just Windows. I find .net a better choice for backend/microservices than Java, for example


Tell us you're not developing for microcontrollers without telling us you're not developing for microcontrollers.


VS developers are okay, it is the VS product managers that are The problem




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: