Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Holy shit, wow so untrue.

Special Relativity was accepted almost immediately (within 10 years) by the scientific community since it was so powerful and useful and correct when the community tested it.

General relativity took a longer time to be generally accepted since the sensitivity of the tests were mediocre for the time, but strong evidence of its correctness was already coming about within 25 years. The problem being it was hard to figure out which model was correct due to lack of accurate tests

Saying that the community rejected these theories is just ignorance.




> within 10 years

> within 25 years

That is "many years" in my view.

> so untrue

So you're saying his ideas were immediately accepted?

I guess that's why he was still working at the patent office for fourish years after his Miracle Year?

And I guess this is like all the other cases where new scientific theories were immediately accepted, of which you can name precisely zero, I imagine?


It’s very few years in physics. Einstein was lucky to see so many outcomes and impacts of his work. Maxwell, Boltzmann, Meitner, noether, and plenty of other physicists didn’t really get to see the impact of their work. But like some things that Einstein predicted, like a BE condensate, were not verified until long after he died.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: