Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> As for a machine writing a novel for me in a matter of milliseconds — I have no idea how that could possibly generate authentic pride or produce anything other than a cavernous inner emptiness?

From my experience trying this. It isn’t quite that easy. The AI has a massive amount of difficulty staying on track and remembering earlier facts when writing a story. There is zero risk of them replacing writers for anything but short stories for now.




More or less my experience.

Sudowrite literally breaks out the story into chapters, and has you arrange all the facts of the story so they can be summarily accessible at all times.


Even making a massive snowflake for the whole story didn’t quite do it for me. It would forget relatively unimportant things, like the character had said something to someone, then three scenes on misremembers what they actually said.


I have had both amazing results, and really shit results.

Like I had it write a cool opening chapter to a short story based on nothing but my notes.

And another time, I had a boxer punch someone 2 floors above him on a balcony.


Huh, wonder if that’s a common thing. I had someone walk down the stairs in a huff, only to teleport back and smack someone in the face :)




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: