As someone whose customers do this stuff, I'm 100% for most academics chasing harder and more important problems.
Most of these papers are specialized increments on high baselines for a primarily commercial problem. Likewise, they focus on optimizing phenomena that occur in their product, which may not occur in others. Eg, Netflix sliding window is neato to see the result of, but I rather students user their freedom to explore bigger ideas like mamba, and leave sliding windows to a masters student who is experimenting with intentionally narrowly scoped tweaks. At that point, to top PhD grads at industrial labs will probably win.
That said, recsys is a general formulation with applications beyond shopping carts and social feeds, and bigger ideas do come out, where I'd expect competitive labs to do projects on. GNN for recsys was a big bet a couple years ago, and LLMs now, and it is curious to me those bigger shifts are industrial labs papers as you say. Maybe the statement there is recsys is one of the areas that industry hires a lot of PhDs on, as it is so core to revenue lift: academia has regular representation, while industry is overrepresented.
Most of these papers are specialized increments on high baselines for a primarily commercial problem. Likewise, they focus on optimizing phenomena that occur in their product, which may not occur in others. Eg, Netflix sliding window is neato to see the result of, but I rather students user their freedom to explore bigger ideas like mamba, and leave sliding windows to a masters student who is experimenting with intentionally narrowly scoped tweaks. At that point, to top PhD grads at industrial labs will probably win.
That said, recsys is a general formulation with applications beyond shopping carts and social feeds, and bigger ideas do come out, where I'd expect competitive labs to do projects on. GNN for recsys was a big bet a couple years ago, and LLMs now, and it is curious to me those bigger shifts are industrial labs papers as you say. Maybe the statement there is recsys is one of the areas that industry hires a lot of PhDs on, as it is so core to revenue lift: academia has regular representation, while industry is overrepresented.