Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Big "whoosh" moment?

"The idea that people with more money should get to decide how people with less money get to spend it."

If it's my tax money, I get to say how it's spent. This is yet another example of the incredibly sad and stupid, "whoever is weakest is rightest", "morality" that's becoming more and more prevalent in the west.



> If it's my tax money, I get to say how it's spent.

No? This has never been how it works.

We all get to decide how it’s spent by voting. You don’t get to individually decide because, obviously, you’re always just gonna choose yourself. In which case - why bother taxing you?

There’s really two camps here: people who think taxation goes towards freeloaders, and people who think taxation goes towards the community.

I’m in the second camp. I believe these things are mutually beneficial. I want to live in a country with less homelessness, less drugs, less violence, less crimes, more education. That costs money, and I’m happy to give it up because I think I DO benefit, just not directly.


[flagged]


You "get a say" when voting, but you do not "get to say" where your money goes exactly. Those phrases have very different meanings, maybe you got them confused


If you were being ironic/sarcastic in your initial comment, that didn't come through for me.

Given the degree of political friction on this (and other) sites, and the fact that for any "obviously" exaggerated point of view you are quite likely to find absolutely sincere adherents ... it would benefit your writing to be clear when you are or aren't being sarcastic.

And to reply in a positive rather than antagonistic tone, particularly if someone's supporting your own viewpoint.

(I'm not certain even this take of mine is valid. However your writing doesn't make your viewpoint clear as it can be read two ways. Which itself raises the temperature within the thread. Avoid that if possible.)




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: