Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You mean the same civil service that was against Brexit from the start, still tries to justify it being a bad idea? Amazing.

You even didn't include the paragraph prior to your quote:

"It's also clear UK services exports - such as advertising and management consulting - have done unexpectedly well since 2021."

I realise Brexit was a horrible shock for the middle classes that they are still coming to terms with, but I think long term it will be neutral or positive. Now that we have a more pro-UK president there is even scope of trade deals with the USA replacing some of the "lost" EU trade.



Right - I included the bottom line on trade. There's plenty more context in the article, and only a small sliver is at all good for the Brexiteer. Everyone agrees it's been between 6-30% worse on the trade front, and the OBR estimate is middle-of-the-road in that regard.

Enjoy the kool-aid.


"Everyone". Everyone said there would be a run on the pound as well.

Stay delusional.


"Would be a run on the pound" is forecasting, just like expecting that Brexit will eventually be neutral or slightly positive. The article reports agreement on past/present facts.


"And the OBR's other working assumption" - Assumptions no more weight than forecasts.


The obr is not the only source here, but one among many.

You seem very invested in ignoring evidence that before wasn't a great idea. This suggests you're more interested in ideology than evidence-based reasoning. It's distressing that "free thinking" has become an excuse to ignore evidence and pursue vibes-based policy.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: