Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

There are easier ways. I'll write a poem and sell it to you for $50 trillion and you draw a picture and I'll buy it for $50 trillion from you. We could get this done today and bump GDP by $100 trillion.



> I'll write a poem and sell it to you for $50 trillion and you draw a picture and I'll buy it for $50 trillion from you. We could get this done today and bump GDP by $100 trillion

Nominally, yes. Real, no. (In practice, given the barter resemblance of the trade, there would be no impact.)


Why is it real GDP when a government contractor makes a PDF report, but isn't real GDP when I make a poem?


Because money paid to the government contractor results in a person (persons?) getting paid along the way and then a large part of that flows into the real economy via consumption / spending.

In your $50 trillion poem example, no money can possibly flow into the real economy because you simply do not have $50 trillion to pay anyone - you're just describing a wash trade of a worthless $50 trillion IOU note not unlike a NFT or crypto memecoin. Best case is that the poem is worth something non-negative.


That's the point.


GDPNow tracks real GDP.


Ah, thanks! Interesting. How does it know which is Real and which is poems?


Ask DOGE ;)


Sales or income tax will be a problem though.


True. We'll probably have to make the poem and picture about Jesus and do it through our new church in New Hampshire.


I hear the standard practice is to have the IP of the poem owned by a foreign entity(Ireland is pretty popular) and then for the US entity to pay a royalty of $50 trillion to the foreign entity so that the net revenue in the US is zero.

I believe it has it's own name - The double Irish.


Yeah but then that only contributes to the GDP of Ireland, not the US.

Not coincidentally, Ireland has one of the highest GDP per capita in the world.


This only works within the European Union because the EU rules allow it.

It would not work between the US and Ireland.


Not if you sell in a state without income tax. And I imagine someone creative can probably find ways to make this not classify as income.


Solve the deficit at the same time!


https://www.bea.gov/system/files/2020-04/GDP-Education-by-BE...

>Who calculates GDP?

>Economists at the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis estimate GDP using thousands of data points gathered by other federal agencies and some private data collectors.

I presume these economists would ignore outliers such as that example, especially ones that would result in unrealistic sales tax or other tax liabilities.

They have a spreadsheet showing sources here:

https://www.bea.gov/data/gdp/gross-domestic-product#:~:text=...


I doubt this sort of chicanery actually happens, or would actually work.


I see you’ve never heard of the market for fine art.


You might not agree that a blank canvas is a $100k "art piece", but assuming both parties are sincere, what's the issue? It's not really any different than some luxury brand selling a $50 (being really generous here) t-shirt for $500.


Their worth is inflated and their whole suite of same artist work increases in value.


That's great for money laundering, but you'd have to pay taxes on it. Good luck.


Unless you leave it in some warehouse by the airport.

> https://hyperallergic.com/51913/the-shadowy-world-of-art-in-...


But then it would not contribute to US GDP, would it?


also NFTs




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: