Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The top 1% make ~800k pa. The bottom 1% make ~15k. Thats over 50x difference.

The difference in life expectancy is 15%. That's 1.15x. And that's including that steepest part right at the front.

You've been bamboozled by the y axis not starting at 0. Someone making 10x more than someone else gets a few % extra life expectancy. Significantly less than just taking a 30 min run a few times a week.



> The difference in life expectancy is 15%.

Which is huge. Life expectancy in the US increased by ~15% between 1955 and now. Surely you would be entirely content with receiving the same level of care as was available back then and inhaling some lead now and then?

> You've been bamboozled by the y axis not starting at 0

It must be fun being so absurdly obtuse. The whole line of reasoning in your comment is so silly that it's hardly worth commenting on.

There is a massive difference between dying before you reach 72 vs living for another 15 years.

The difference in avg. life expectancy between Germany and Ethiopia is less than that.

Again, surely there is no measurable difference between living in either place when you are making median income?


The difference is less than those who exercise v not, slightly larger than that between men and women. For 50x chance in income. Money simply isn't as big a differentiator in life as you desperately want it to be. And that's the tiny bit of common sense required.


> Money simply isn't as big a differentiator

It seems by your standards nothing is. Yet if you add it all together instead of looking at a single indicator money is inarguably (if you have any arguments or data please share them) statistically the biggest differentiator compared to anything else besides congenital diseases and other health conditions we can't treat yet.

> And that's the tiny bit of common sense required

Well having more than a "tiny bit" of common sense would made it obvious than it's not the case.

> For 50x chance in income.

Directly comparing wealth/income ratios and absolute differences in life expectancy or other indicator just makes no sense and claiming that it somehow proves something. Having only a tiny bit of knowledge about statistics would make that obvious.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: