Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I didn't say it wasn't.


Creating a false equivalency between intolerance of the intolerant and intolerance of others / other groups is a key rhetorical device for fascists.

Even if you've walked to this position through "logic" and a concept of perfectly spherical human beings [0], with no steps through fascism, you should be aware of how this position is used by fascists to give themselves a veneer of rationality while painting their opponents as irrational.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spherical_cow

To put it another way: https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/578682-adolf-hitler


I didn't create a false equivalence.


Ok this time I'll put as much effort into my reply as you did:

Yes you did.


They actually didn't and I don't know why you think they did.


>Seems like a typical mythos of most political movements these days, doesn't it? E.g., "the far-right is our greatest threat".

>Though I'm sure right-wing groups believe themselves to be tolerant of one-another and their allies and others with similar aims, and that groups that oppose them are intolerant and therefore must be met with intolerance.

>Other side will call them intolerant racists too, it is also pretty clear to them.

These would be the statements where they were creating a false equivalence. The things being compared are not equivalent but they are given rhetorical treatment to make them seem equivalent.


From what I can tell, they simply made an observation. You're the one applying a value judgment to their statements. Pointing out that different tribes use rhetoric to "other" outsiders isn't creating a false equivalence.


Congrats, you've bought into the fascist's messaging.


You're very intolerant of people discussing this subject.


I'm intolerant of fascist messaging.


Denouncing and accusing people as fascists who must not be tolerated for the transgression of discussing social and political issues in a manner deemed verboten seems like something a fascist might do.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: