Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This paywall product must have required a staggering amount of work. And yet, the entire text of the article is right there in the network tab.

Why send it over the wire, then try to hide it?



I use Win10, Firefox (latest) and the "Open in Reader View" add-on. So when I right-click the link and select "Open in Reader View" on the menu, it bypasses all the scripts and shows me the full text.

This is how I open 99% of any links on HN or anywhere else (i.e. wanting to read a news article)(I always open in reader view to avoid menus/columns/ads/etc.)


It's (deliberately) a very soft paywall. The LRB offers a certain number of articles for free then hope to attract subscribers, but it's only really a semi-commercial proposition. The whole thing has been subsidised by the editor for decades; my suspicion is that they're much more interested in being read than being paid.

FWIW I'm a subscriber at least in the main because I want it to exist. Most months I don't read more than I'd get for free anyway. But it's gloriously chewy content of a kind that you can't quite find anywhere else.


Huh, it's not paywalled for me. I'm using Brave and have a robust Pihole situation but.. yeah it's all there


The people who write the content and build the site are different from the people who want the paywall?

Usually when it's that obvious, it's general courtesy not to go pointing it out.


It seems intentional, though?

* There's an animation hiding it.

* If you disable javascript, the content doesn't load.

* Copying is disabled.

* There's some kind of javascript function constantly toggling state so that if you right-click inspect, the content div collapses before you can further unroll it.

Someone really wanted users to see the article, then watch it disappear, and make them feel a sense of loss.


Well that's _clearly_ a violation of the CFAA! \s

Once the manager wasn't able to see the text whoever did this was able to click "done" on the ticket and move on.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: