Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Money that is loaned out is still accounted for as liabilities.

To be clear:

* Money is "loaned out" in the sense that a bank credits your account.

* Money is not loaned out in the sense that which "goes into" your account did not come out of someone else's account. Rather it was created 'out of thin air' by the bank without reference to anyone else's deposits.




To be clear:

I am familiar with your links, for quite some time actually.

I never said that the money came out of someone else's account.

What I did say was that it was accounted for as liabilities. It's the bank's liability to the loanee (or their bank), which the bank absolutely can be obliged to pay with reserves or cold hard cash (and it can only get these from borrowing, selling assets or customers paying cash into their account).

And so banks lend it out to people attached to a slightly larger liability repayable to them and keep track, because if they don't all this money they're "printing" represents losses in terms of obligations they can't "print" their way out of. That's quite different from the ledger screwup its being compared with, or indeed people creating tokens (not backed by debt or anything else) out of thin air to sell to other people


You're going to have to show the balance sheet movements because your wordy description is very woolly.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: