Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Brexit was a special case of stupid. There should never have been a referendum with such a stupid question, devoid of any context or potential impact.

Democracy only works when voters are informed.



> Democracy only works when voters are informed.

Since most people in the world aren't informed nor wants to be informed, are you saying democracy doesn't work in the real world?


It sure looks like it, doesn't it. The outlook in Europe is also bleak. The cult is strong and with Trumps victory will only get stronger.


There's actually some interesting context there.

Shortly before the Brexit referendum, Scotland had an independence referendum, where the Westminster government was in favour of the status quo - and they had a great deal of success by deliberately not figuring out what independence would mean.

What currency would an independent Scotland use? What will happen to their military? What about healthcare, and education? EU membership? What share of the UK's national debt would they take on? Who will get citizenship? What will the border look like? Nobody knows! So a yes vote was a scary leap into the unknown with many unsolved problems, while a no vote was safe and predictable.

After the strategy succeeded in the Scottish independence vote, Cameron decided to repeat that success with Brexit - not figuring out what Brexit means was a deliberate strategy intended to boost the remain campaign.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: