Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

  >"they fail to see the systematic risks"
  Or they also fail at providing a solution.
Apple has no incentive to improve Safari. "It just works" is what their cultists paid to have the honor to parrot, and they enjoy the majority of web market share of people with actual wages and disposable income. That's why the sell culture, not their people's data (directly, yet).

Since it's not "Safari" that's broken (since iPhones cost a lot of money, they cant break), the users will lie blame at the fault of the web developers, since they had gotten cozy within the comfortable, flexible, expected behaviors of Chrome, having enjoyed a hiatus from IE11 EOL pollyfills and jquery.

Apple then made it easier to roll out an app than to grapple with the pitfalls, nuances, foot-guns, and gabbling documentation that Safari has carefully mal-compiled to shepherd both developers and their users into the Walled Garden.

It's just the browser wars, but with higher stakes. And Microsoft already won.




If you’re referring to people as “cultists”, consider that your point might not be as strong as you think. If you have a non-emotional argument about a browser, try making it with logic and data rather than emotion. For example, demonstrate awareness of where the browsers rank on the features which web developers really need (Google’s devrel team likes to highlight PWA features almost nobody uses even on Chrome) and show why the “walled garden” metaphor applies more to a niche browser than the dominant one by a large margin.


good points.

They are both using the innate incompatibilities between browsers to further entrench their mobile device market share positions.

Safari is (unanimously) shit - even without Google's PWA's moot gloating.

Apple disallows browsers other than Safari, and have deprecated Windows/Android versions.

  >how why the “walled garden” metaphor applies more to a niche browser than the dominant one

(social)-cultism, signaling of wealth, hostile towards outsiders...




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: