Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Note there is a concept traffic engineers use called "the 85th percentile rule" that helps design highways by setting the speed limit for maximum compliance. Using this rule leads to the safest roads.

The fundamental flaw in this concept is that it completely ignores that 1) the ideal speed depends on external circumstances and intended road use, and that 2) road design heavily influences driving speed. If you want to have a safe road network, you have to design it for a specific speed. When done properly, drivers will naturally be driving at the intended speed. Speeding doesn't happen because it doesn't feel safe to speed.

Highways have to be straight and wide, without any level crossings. People are supposed to drive at high speeds, so it is designed in such a way that it is safe to do so, and it feels safe to do so. Local access roads are narrow, twisty, have relatively poor visibility, and are equipped with things like speed bumps. You're supposed to drive at slow speeds because there are lots of level crossings and driveways, so they are intentionally designed to make high-speed driving unsafe to the point of being physically impossible.



Maybe my wording is confusing, but the idea is not flawed. It is used to set the speed limit, given the road.

If you want a lower speed limit, you can just set it, and if below the 85th percentile speed, you'll get a less safe road.

The proper way to do it would be to adjust the characteristics of the road so that drivers slow down and the speed variance is minimized.

Same for increasing the limit. A wider or smoother or straighter road may work.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: