Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This should be a lesson for free-market advocates, especially those who see the US economic boom as a result of laissez-faire economics. In reality there are opportunities the free market doesn't take, and wise government intervention can yield enormous benefit to the public.


You may be right, but your conclusion doesn't follow from the article.


In reality what we call 'capitalism' is unstable and requires continual intervention to survive.


That is a very simplistic perspective of 'capitalism', it is a bit more nuance than that. It typically requires intervention to prevent it from destroying the economy because of insider trading, liquidity, and monopolist practices. The only criticism you say about it mirror aspect of our-selves that we don't like to admit. It isn't perfect but people are not perfect how-ever based on how fast we're pull people out poverty, you have to admit its pretty good!


Do you feel that the free market wouldn't have adopted it at some future point in time?


I don't believe the free market would ever have produced the heavy presses. The coordination problem between making designs that use the heavy press and the investment to make the presses is essentially the prisoner's dilemma - each actor reaps a large reward if they both commit but loses massively if only they commit. The outcome is that they don't commit, especially if you add in real-world factors like alternate uses of the investment that competition tends to force the businesses involved into. The only hope would be something vertically integrated that can commit both, but there's no particular reason to believe that such an enterprise could enter into the market.

The free market probably could and would have optimized the situation at hand. Machining would have become cheaper, solutions to the fastener issues mentioned would be found and so on. This might even end up being better than the heavy presses - that's a technical question not an economic one - although the article makes it sound like the forging solution really is inherently superior.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: