Newcastle and Sheffield ran over eastern leg, Newcastle especially benefiting on services to Birmingham.
Liverpool on the western leg. I always felt landing the leg south of Acton bridge was odd as it meant you still had the winsford bottleneck, but again better service to Birmingham and London
Improved services from Liverpool to Manchester relies on the airport-centre leg in Manchester to avoid castlefield and Stockport bottlenecks
So much coolaid being drunk
Note how Sheffield, Newcastle and Liverpool aren't in any HS2 plans...
I'm in favour of rail projects. I just dislike the dishonesty about the benefits