> I'm not concerned with this question as it implies that people haven't got a choice between "rent modem, ez for noobs" and "buy own equipment, fully control it."
If you buy the equipment from Verizon, I will bet you a significant amount of money that it still sends your passwords to them [on edit: with exactly zero disclosure that's detectable to 99.99 percent of users]. In fact, I'll bet you Verizon treats customer-owned equipment exactly like rented equipment except in billing. But anyway.
> The people who would trust the ISP-owned device likely have already typed that wi-fi password into things like $99 smart TVs which probably transmit their wifi password, location, and microphone data directly to China. Verizon having the wifi password is not cause for concern here.
You park your car in bad neighborhoods. Had I not stolen your car, somebody else would have done it.
OK, I forgot we're talking about FiOS here. For sure that is slightly weirder than DOCSIS (which is all I've ever known personally). Since it's not really a standard like DOCSIS you probably "must have" some piece of Verizon-proprietary gear whether rented or otherwise and I'm sure Verizon remote-manages those in the same basic ways like you said. But I am pretty sure that still, security-conscious or advanced users can disable the Verizon device's WiFi and drop it into bridge mode and provide their own router and APs. To me this provides a way to opt out of this that is well within the capabilities of anyone sophisticated enough to understand the risks.
If you buy the equipment from Verizon, I will bet you a significant amount of money that it still sends your passwords to them [on edit: with exactly zero disclosure that's detectable to 99.99 percent of users]. In fact, I'll bet you Verizon treats customer-owned equipment exactly like rented equipment except in billing. But anyway.
> The people who would trust the ISP-owned device likely have already typed that wi-fi password into things like $99 smart TVs which probably transmit their wifi password, location, and microphone data directly to China. Verizon having the wifi password is not cause for concern here.
You park your car in bad neighborhoods. Had I not stolen your car, somebody else would have done it.