I'm going to come out and state the root of the problem.
I can't trust remote AI, any more than I can trust a remote website.
If someone else is running the code, they can switch it up anytime. Imagine trusting someone who simulates everything you need to trust them, giving them all your private info, and then screws you over in an instant. AI is capable of it far more than biological beings with "costly signals".
If it's open source, and I can run it locally, I can verify that it doesn't phone home, and the weights can be audited by others.
Just like I wouldn't want to spend 8 hours a day in a metaverse owned by Zuck, or an "everything app" owned by Elon, why would I want to give everything over to a third party AI?
I like Ilya. I like Elon. I like Moxie Marlinspike and Pavel Durov. But would I trust their companies to read all my emails, train their data on them, etc.? And hope nothing leaks?
And of course then there is the issue of the AI being trained to do what they want, just like their sites do what they want, which in the case of Twitter / Facebook is not healthy for society at large, but creates angry echo chambers, people addicted to stupid arguing and videos.
I think there have to be standards for open source AI, and something far better than Langchain (which sucks). This is what I think it should look like: https://engageusers.ai/ecosystem.pdf -- what do you think?
I can't trust remote AI, any more than I can trust a remote website.
If someone else is running the code, they can switch it up anytime. Imagine trusting someone who simulates everything you need to trust them, giving them all your private info, and then screws you over in an instant. AI is capable of it far more than biological beings with "costly signals".
If it's open source, and I can run it locally, I can verify that it doesn't phone home, and the weights can be audited by others.
Just like I wouldn't want to spend 8 hours a day in a metaverse owned by Zuck, or an "everything app" owned by Elon, why would I want to give everything over to a third party AI?
I like Ilya. I like Elon. I like Moxie Marlinspike and Pavel Durov. But would I trust their companies to read all my emails, train their data on them, etc.? And hope nothing leaks?
And of course then there is the issue of the AI being trained to do what they want, just like their sites do what they want, which in the case of Twitter / Facebook is not healthy for society at large, but creates angry echo chambers, people addicted to stupid arguing and videos.
I think there have to be standards for open source AI, and something far better than Langchain (which sucks). This is what I think it should look like: https://engageusers.ai/ecosystem.pdf -- what do you think?