> I've saved a Welling paper from rejection from two reviewers who admitted to not knowing PDEs
Thank you for fighting the good fight.
This is why I love OpenReview, I can spot and ignore nonsensical reviewer criticisms and ratings and look for the insightful comments and rebuttals. Many reviewers do put in a lot of very valuable work reading and critiquing most of which would go to waste if not made public.
I like OR too and I wish we would just post to there instead. It has everything we need, and I see no value from the venues. No one wants to act in good faith and they have every incentive not to.
And I gotta say, I'm not going to put up a fight much longer. As soon as I get out of my PhD I intend to just post to OR.
Thank you for fighting the good fight.
This is why I love OpenReview, I can spot and ignore nonsensical reviewer criticisms and ratings and look for the insightful comments and rebuttals. Many reviewers do put in a lot of very valuable work reading and critiquing most of which would go to waste if not made public.