This sounds like a really good way of approaching it. From what I understand the argument against is clear but enforcing it in the face of peer pressure a little more complicated!
My nephews school allows basic 'dumb' phones but not smart phones which seems a fair compromise.
Yes, the peer pressure is exactly the point. The older your child is, the more his peers will influence his behavior. I hope by the time he goes to middle school, I'll find a school with this kind of restrictions.
My nephews school allows basic 'dumb' phones but not smart phones which seems a fair compromise.