Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Re-thinking electronic mail (2022) (liw.fi)
4 points by Brajeshwar on March 14, 2024 | hide | past | favorite | 3 comments



Email is a tottering stack of standards which mostly-but-not-completely solve problems discovered over time. As the article states it would be a good target for a complete rethink, but I don't think any of the solutions presented are promising avenues to explore.

As one example, consider the proposed "recipient stamps". It requires a complex trust configuration, always-on email clients, and synchronizing 'stamp books' across different clients. I expect that makes it intractable in practice.

Better would be 'postage' where each email contains references to one or more payment methods. The receiver and intermediaries can then deduct a fee from any available payment methods at their discretion. Some common postage methods would be a hashcash service, or crypto-currency address, or pre-approved captcha credits, or a service to request a moderately large Internet transfer.


Yes, great. So then every email leaves a digital financial footprint to trace! Which also, (in the U.S.) means you need a bank account. That bank, requires KYC. You've just removed the houseless and poor from the emailing public.


None of the payment mechanisms I suggested do anything of the sort. In fact none of them involve a bank at all.

And since the receiver can choose to not cash in the postage, the postage need not be validated at all.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: