Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Station wagons are tanky; minivans are homely and underpowered. So lots of people get SUVs. It’s easier to fit things in the trunk when shopping IKEA or going skiing, sports equipment, etc. sure, it is possible to wedge 10ft 2x4s in a sedan, but it’s easier with an SUV.

In any case, normal SUVs are not class signifiers. People drive beaters. Some are signifiers but that’s a really small segment.



“Homely”?

Avoiding something because it’s “homely” sounds exactly like symboling status :)


Plus "underpowered". Like, what? You can't revv your engine that well at the red light or what are we talking about?


> Station wagons are tanky;

I'm sorry what? Tanky compared to an overbuilt overpowered 17 foot suburban?!

The old woodies are a thing of beauty and a Mercedes estate is downright gorgeous, and would utterly SCHOOL an Escalade on cargo capacity AND fuel economy at the same time.

> minivans are homely and underpowered.

Then get a VAN, not a MINI-VAN. It's in the name dude.

> So lots of people get SUVs. It’s easier to fit things in the trunk when shopping IKEA or going skiing, sports equipment, etc. sure, it is possible to wedge 10ft 2x4s in a sedan, but it’s easier with an SUV.

I'm sorry that last statement is just laughable. Long cargo is AWFUL in an SUV unless you remove the entire rear row of seats at which point, again, you have a van. You have a tall, shitty van.


Most modern SUVs are 'underpowered' too. They take the same lame engine that goes in a non-sport family sedan and drop it in a larger, heavier car. If you want performance, you usually buy a specific type of car.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: