Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Because your children are not your property, they are your responsibility

I couldn’t possibly agree more! They are MY responsibility. Not yours. Not the state’s. Not society’s. I will educate them the way that I see fit. It’s not my responsibility to educate your kids, and it’s not your responsibility to educate mine, no matter how righteous and justified it may feel.



Within limits.

If you are teaching your children to murder all Jews and that red traffic lights mean go, then you are clearly not capable of being responsible for another human being.


But surely you can recognize the difference between simply teaching your child an evidence-dry religious worldview, and teaching them to actively hate and murder people or break laws that would endanger others?

I agree, within reason is always necessary, and if those things were being taught then it's time for a visit from CPS, for sure. But it still feels like a potential slippery slope of "You're abusing this child by teaching them things that aren't approved by the state" in the extreme case. I know that may sound silly, but with as polarized as the country has been recently, and with authoritarianism on the rise worldwide (I saw a man get arrested in the UK yesterday because he criticized some protests on Facebook!), I don't see it being an entirely foreign idea.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: