Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There will be more companies making things and providing things than there are today because there’s more labor available. We can do the things that aren’t of higher necessity today.


To sell to who? If no one has income, who buys the things?


Income can be generated politically, see e.g. Soviet command economy.


In Soviet economy virtually all people had a job though. In communist Poland where I grew, safe for the years of martial law in mid 80s everyone who wanted a job had one.


In our modern economy everyone that wants a job has one. Unemployment is extremely low and has been.


That's only true of the US in this very moment, it's not a property of capitalism per se.


New businesses will form. Why wouldn't they? We have a ton of businesses that even 50 years ago no one would imagine. We can continue up the pyramid to more and more things that wouldn’t be possible or practical today.

Your mistake is you’re looking at a future world in todays state.


Why would they? There is nothing suggesting that there are infinite industries to be invented, once we have automated our core industries, will we all be working for superfluous industries? Seems far more naive to assume the status quo of total employment will continue due to some unforseen future of yet known new jobs, rather than thinking criticaly about the more near future outcomes of a much deeper automation of jobs we already have.


This is similar to:

Replacing horses with cars will free up those horses to do other productive work, like pulling plows and turning stone mills, thereby benifiting the horses.


I don’t agree because horses are extremely limited in function compared to humans. There is a very small set of things horses are useful for and you’re right, we’ve mechanized most of them.


Neoliberal economics is so exhausting.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: