Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Fucking hell, here we go again: "Dash cams are much more tightly regulated in some parts of the EU than elsewhere."

It depends on the eu country of which there are several...including an ex-eu country.

How it comes accross: One of the things i hate about America is that in new york all the californian building restrictions and zoning are killing free speech.



Preach it brother


With respect, the GDPR is a Regulation and this applies uniformly across the bloc. Enforcement varies, obviously.

TBH your comment comes off as very condescending and ill-informed.


GDPR is to be implemented independently in each country. There is room for interpretation, it's not a granitic ruleset from above


No, that's not correct.

When talking about the EU, there are two types of laws (well, three if you include treaties), Directives and Regulations.

Directives are common goals which much be transposed into law by each country and there is indeed differences in implementation. An example of a directive is Directive 2012/27/EU on energy efficiency. It set goals on energy efficiency (and minimum targets), but each country implemented it's own legislation to transpose the Directive into law, and those implementations varied wildly.

However, EU Regulations are a different kettle of fish. Regulations are EU legal acts which are immediately enforceable as national law in all EU states. GDPR is a Regulation and so applies uniformly across the bloc.

Regulations are designed to harmonise legislation across the entire bloc. Obviously there are differences in enforcement, but the ultimate arbiter is the CJEU and decisions are binding in all EU states.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: