Claims of code of conduct violations on the basis that the technical proposal itself is a violation of the Positive Work Environment provisions is a stretch. It is, however, a clear violation of the Priority of Constituencies[1], including the dictum about who is in control: the Web must enhance individuals' control and power[2].
Having said that, the comment that Weiss links to when citing himself...:
> I understand many folks here are upset about this proposal. I urge you to actually read the proposal, rather than rely on rumors about what it does or doesn't propose. If it's at all helpful, I wrote a few words about ways you can constructively engage with proposals you don't like.
... almost certainly does run afoul of the W3C's provisions for acceptable and unacceptable behavior outlined in the code of ethics and professional conduct. Implying that someone who is "upset" about the proposal is responding to rumors and that it is okay to admonish them to "actually read [it]" is both uncharitable and noxious to the discussion. There's a good reason why HN, for example, has an explicit rule against accusing people of not having read the article.
Having said that, the comment that Weiss links to when citing himself...:
> I understand many folks here are upset about this proposal. I urge you to actually read the proposal, rather than rely on rumors about what it does or doesn't propose. If it's at all helpful, I wrote a few words about ways you can constructively engage with proposals you don't like.
... almost certainly does run afoul of the W3C's provisions for acceptable and unacceptable behavior outlined in the code of ethics and professional conduct. Implying that someone who is "upset" about the proposal is responding to rumors and that it is okay to admonish them to "actually read [it]" is both uncharitable and noxious to the discussion. There's a good reason why HN, for example, has an explicit rule against accusing people of not having read the article.
1. <https://www.w3.org/TR/design-principles/#priority-of-constit...>
2. <https://www.w3.org/TR/ethical-web-principles/#control>