Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Science be damned! Onwards with subjectivity!

• 24-bit audio is magical. When I recorded myself playing guitar in 24-bit and played it back through my amp, it sounded like I was still playing. 16-bit sounded like a CD.

• With MP3s, 192 kbps is a huge step up from 128 kbps. 192 doesn't exhibit any of the "swooshiness" heard in the upper range of 128 kbps MP3s for regular rock/pop/hiphop music.



I believe you are confusing 192kbit compression with 192 khz sampling rate. Not at all the same thing.


Whoops! Guess I'll read more carefully, then.


ahem 192 kHz. We're talking sampling frequency, not bitrate.


The article states that greater than 16 bit has value in recording, just not in playback. If you took your 24 bit recording and translated the best 16 bits of it than output it through your 24 bit DAC then they are saying you won't here a difference. I say output through your 24 bit DAC so you aren't simply hearing a better DAC.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: