Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Blockchains are unnecessary in a world with trusted entities and functional legal frameworks. In places that require a blockchain, you're still going to be at the whim of whomever has a monopoly on force. Sure, your key passphrase may be in your head. You'll end up getting beat with a rubber hose. It was never your crypto so long as someone has the guns (wrt "Not your keys, not your crypto").

https://xkcd.com/538/

> A massive decoupling from US economy. I wonder what people call US economy if they call crypto pyramid scheme. Sitting on trillions and trillions of debt, printing money according to their will completely ignoring the effect of their childish actions on the global economy

US Treasuries would like a word (they are the safest financial asset in the world, "full faith and credit"). There is no safer capital market than the US. Sure, there will be some de-dollarization, but that won't fix a rapidly aging China, a "teetering near the cliff" Russia, a Central and South America that is slow steady state, etc. And Africa? Very young still but a hard sell for investing.

> Sitting on trillions and trillions of debt, printing money according to their will completely ignoring the effect of their childish actions on the global economy

Debt backed by future productivity, but also debt that can also always take a haircut during legal proceedings. Laws and courts > smart contracts, broadly speaking.



> Blockchains are unnecessary in a world with trusted entities and functional legal frameworks.

This is also an argument against end-to-end encryption and against federated protocols. The reality is that we, in fact, do not have and have never managed to maintain trusted entities and functional legal frameworks for much else... why do you think this is so different?


> Blockchains are unnecessary in a world with trusted entities and functional legal frameworks.

This is such bullshit. In practice the banking system is a messed up piece of old crap.

Let me illustrate my point from my experience a few weeks ago: Had to transfer 20 euro's from my account to my sons account, same European bank. In fact, my sons account is also under my supervision. It was on a Saturday, so guess what: no transfers in the weekend! Had to wait until Monday for the money to go through. Yeah, if Monday was a Holiday, we had to wait until Tuesday.

Is that the efficiency your "trusted entities" can come up with? Don't get me started on "instant cross border transfers". If a well known bank can't handle 20 euro's from one account to another, then what do you expect cross-bank, cross-border does?

In contrast, look at the Nano cryptocurrency: 0 fees, sub second transfers, any amount, anywhere in the world.

Your theory of "trusted entities" all sounds nice, but in practice it's old bureaucratic bullshit. Thanks to blockchain the technology has a solution. Only now is still proper adoption.


That sounds like a problem with your bank, or you don't know how to do the transfer correctly.

I can transfer euros from my bank to a bank in a different EU country within seconds at no cost around the clock all days of the year.


It's KBC, 15th largest bank in Europe.

> I can transfer euros from my bank to a bank in a different EU country within seconds

Yeah, I want to see you try to send it to KBC. Good luck with that. I'm sure it won't be the only bank in Europe with that issue.

Secondly, I want to see you try it with >20k euro transfers.


It’s worse, in many (most? all?) cases a legal backing is superior!




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: