Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I mean that’s the whole point of federation right??

The point of federation is not to be dependent on oligopolies from a single country, one with poor grasp of and legal enforcement of personal privacy at that.

>It kinda loses its point.

Even if it comes to this, it doesn't. Another migration can happen at any point, but this time you wouldn't lose your social contacts - and in the future hopefully neither your content.

>But Google and Microsoft got in the game.

That's like your common anti-Linux argument.

>Search engine indexing for these federated services SUCKS.

Decentralized content/link aggregators just became popular so we'll see what'll happen, but personal social media shouldn't be as public for most people as it right now anyway.



> not to be dependent on oligopolies from a single country, one with poor grasp of and legal enforcement of personal privacy at that.

The oligopolies from a single country might get replaced by groups of instances who will claim they're holders of the Truth and who are the Service, while rest is dangerous. Nothing also stops countries from running own instances or compatible services by dedicated companies or people to either dominate or lure people out of the federation. A good campaign, attractive interface and features and people will follow.

The remaining option is to "run your own instance" but in time when the federation will most likely solidify enough it might be hard to do so. Hard as in getting people to join your new playground. What we're seeing right now it's a boom period.

Don't get me wrong, I do like concept of federated services but there's too many sides where it might fail in long-term and help create a highly tribalized echo-chambered communities




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: