Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What does proactive medicine look like? Or do you just mean eating healthy and exercising? Everyone knows you should be doing that.


Correct. Proactive medicine would be to prescribe a healthy lifestyle that’s customized for an individual. Traditional medicine like Ayurveda tries to do that. It’s kind of baffling that western medicine doesn’t really think like that.


Medicine does care about prevention, in fact we have the USPSTF who's sole focus is prevention!

With respects to diet and activity, there is a grade C recommendation to provide counseling to patients without risk factors[0] and grade B for those with risk factors[1]. Both (as with all USPSTF recommendations) have associated evidence summaries and provide rationales for the strength of the recommendations.

[0] https://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/recomme...

[1] https://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/uspstf/recomme...


Proactive medicine.

You wake up in the morning and have a piss. Your piss is measured for various chemicals from simple ions to proteins. It detects you have too much sodium so it communicates to your food dispenser and your bacon ration is reduced. (Yes that's from The Island.) You then get dressed in front of a camera which counts your moles and freckles. It sees a new one so you get a notification that your Touch Grass(TM) session is shortened.

When you get to work your workstation monitors your alertness to ensure you sleep enough. It detects your attention drifting 5% more than tolerated so another notification comes in letting you know Lights Out(R) is now 15 minutes earlier.

You attend a social gathering after work but your purchase of an alcoholic beverage is denied because a blood test last week showed a liver enzyme was elevated 1% out of the baseline range.


You posit these interventions like any of them have a shred of evidence to suggest they're effective (or that we actually have reference ranges and test accuracy for what you're suggesting) and conveniently ignore civil liberties.

"liver enzyme was elevated 1% out of the baseline range" is medically meaningless but let's pretend the patient is cirrhotic so your hypothetical is valid, this individual has a constitutionally protected right to be an idiot and continue drinking themselves into death.


You do not have a right to damage government property. You must live so that you can pay taxes. The government will ensure this. When you are no longer productive you will be prescribed MAID.


It’s data driven.

You get tested every few years and adjust diet/supplements/exercise based on the findings.


Random screening are more harmful than useful. Overdiagnosis[0] is a thing.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overdiagnosis


The devil is in the detail.

> It’s data driven.

Good.

> You get tested every few years

Not always good. Many screening tests just increase unnecessary procedure except in very specific situations. Eg MRI screening generates a ton on unnecessary biopsies and associated complications, stress.

The data says when screening is appropriate, so as you say, use the data.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: