Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Most useful conversations have moved to messaging apps.

That's not a future I'd like to ever live in.

Why? Because all of those are proprietary solutions that don't interoperate with anything and their behavior and existence depend on the whims of a single corporation. No thanks.

Email is standard, interoperable, owned by nobody, accessible to everyone. It's the optimal way to communicate.



I dont know how to upvote this enough.

So many people completely miss this point. If whatever is supposed to replace email it will have to be very similar in features. That is

1. Permissionless (open for anyone to send messages or operate a server) 2. Asynchronous 3. Resilient 4. Searchable

No IM solutions I know can do that at all. Matrix would come closest but asynchronicity and resilience are still troublesome on that part and all clients are more geared towards IM instead of async longform discourse


Email is owned by gmail at this point


While one could heavily overgeneralize and say that "everyone uses google for mail" (iirc they own like 20% of the email market) they certainly don't own the protocol or its development.

I think it is exactly these sentiments that do most harm.


> Email is owned by gmail at this point

I mean, that is completely false at every level (technical and operational).

Sure, gmail is a big player but there are many others. Most importantly, there are thousands of smaller players. All of which interoperate.

I can't tell if you say that sarcastically or from a position on being uninformed about how email works. If the latter, do take some time to understand email infrastructure at a high level because it is a case study in beautiful interoperability of open standards. Something we must all keep in mind for the future of the Internet.

Email has been resilient and an open communication mechanism from everyone since the 70s precisely because it cannot be owned by anyone, it is an open interoperable standard.

There will never be anything equally long-lived and feature rich from a single corporation. Corporate interest don't align with that. Proprietary solutions will always be about locking you in and limiting interoperability.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: