Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That article is pure fantasy.

The South didn't need any help walking away from a peace deal in '68. Hell, they walked away from the peace deal in '72 and only signed because Nixon told them the US was leaving regardless.

And there was no peace deal in '68 with the North. The North wasn't even interested in negotiating until a couple years after Nixon got into office.

And funny how Nixon gets blamed for "prolonging" a war he never started. How about blame JFK and LBJ for starting and escalating it into a massive conflict?



So this investigation, including the tape recordings referenced, are fantasy? https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-21768668

Perhaps it's easier to believe this about Nixon given his other documented crimes. Or you can just browse the transcripts here to get an idea of what he was willing to do and what his motivations were for making decisions. https://www.nixonlibrary.gov/watergate-trial-tapes


It’s pure fantasy.

Yes, Nixon did tell the South that he could get them a better deal if they waited until after the election.

But the idea that the US and North Vietnam were on the verge of a peace deal in ‘68 is just laughable.

And sure Nixon did lots of things wrong, but that doesn’t mean I automatically believe some article that makes a preposterous conclusion.


> Nixon did tell the South that he could get them a better deal if they waited until after the election

So whether a more immediate peace deal was likely or not, he made an effort to postpone it. And he had specific personal reasons for wanting it postponed.

Given the other actions he took for personal gain, why should we believe this was any different?

But at this point, we're way outside HN boundaries. So I'll leave it alone.


> But the idea that the US and North Vietnam were on the verge of a peace deal in ‘68 is just laughable.

North and South Vietnam weren't on the verge of peace, but the US could easily have had peace at any time by withdrawing.


That’s not peace that’s capitulation.


There is more than enough blame to go around.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: