Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Just because 2 things are related does not mean they are equally dangerous. Potatoes, tomatos, eggplants, and most peppers are in the Solanaceae family, same as deadly nightshade (Atropa belladonna), which is extremely poisonous. Yet potatoes are a staple crop.

The commonly consumed pea types (yellow, sweet, snap, snow) have no risk of causing Lathyrism. Only wild peas pose a risk and those are outright banned in most nations. (notable exception, india, where it is part of several common dishes).



You have been warned. Plants are unsafe to eat by default

The fact that wild peas are much more dangerous does not remove the danger from common sweet peas (of any kind or color, Is the same species). Is a matter of how much of it you eat, and if you allow enough days between meals to detox.

It depends also in "how" you eat it. If you mix it with cereals or not (hint, you should) and even in "where" you cook it.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15679560/


> You have been warned.

You are spreading FUD.

The link you've provided is yet another study on wild peas (grass pea is a wild pea, Lathyrus sativus, just a different name).

Show me the study that links sweet pea, Lathyrus odoratus, consumption with Neurolathyrism.

The only danger to eating sweet peas is when you eat them in combination with eating wild peas. [1]

The pea types I listed do not cause lathyrism without being mixed with Lathyrus sativus.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osteolathyrism


Maybe a lost in translation case

By common sweet pea, I mean the green common edible one. Pisum sativum = Lathyrus sativus a species that is known to cause the disease if eaten in large amounts. Lathyrism is happening still today in a few parts of the planet like India, and is a serious irreversible condition, not much unlike paraplegia. This is not FUD, is a proven medical fact. Maybe the vegetable has a different name in English. Dunno, but we are talking about the same species all the time.

Lathyrus odoratus, is the Fragrant sweet pea, a small species with huge flowers that smell really well. It has tiny peas that are not really edible -in big amounts- (all are "edible" in very small quantities but it does not worth the risk) and of course, as most Lathyrus it causes lathyrism. is just that is a different case of Lathyrism, affecting bones instead nerves if I remember correctly.


Pisum sativum and Lathyrus sativus are not the same plant. Pisum sativum’s Lathyrus name is “Lathyrus oleraceus”

Lathyrus sativus is also referred to as the “white pea”. Because it’s white.

I know sativus and sativum look the same but that doesn’t mean they are the same plant.

Here’s an article with photos of Lathyrus sativus. [1]

If I may inquire, are you from india? If so, then yes, you probably do have to be more aware of the peas you are eating. From the articles I can find it sounds like Lathyrus sativus is banned in india but still somewhat commonly sold. That’s not the case where I’m at in the US. You cannot accidentally get Lathyrus sativus here because nobody is selling it.

[1] https://india.mongabay.com/2019/05/toxic-debate-rages-on-ove...


Hmm, I could be wrong... Let me check it.

Yep. The International Plant Names lists 33 synonims for Pisum sativum L. and 16 for Lathyrus sativus L. and none of them coincide. Botanical names are changing all the time, and is not straightforward sometimes.

So you were right and I was wrong. I stand corrected. Thank you for getting me out of my mistake.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: