Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I can’t for the life of me figure out how they're losing so much money, yet their product is still far more expensive than actual beef.

Can a more informed follower provide some insight? Are they just grossly mismanaging their production costs?



Creating "actual beef" used to be fairly expensive, but, over the decades, companies have found out how to produce it for as cheap as possible, while still earning billions in profits, without consumers feeling as though beef is expensive. That efficiency comes with time. Plant-based meat is still in its infancy by comparison. So, even though the costs to consumers is high, the amount of profit the plant-based companies earn may be similar, or even lower than, what the beef industry earns.

Then there's Beyond itself. Striking a deal with McDonald's likely involved a lot of time and money — and then the "McPlant" product immediately failed. If you're going to convince Americans that plant-based meat is good, meeting them where they're at with fast food may seem like a good idea. But the type of people who find themselves in the McDonald's drive-thru, and the type of people who will pay extra for plant-based meat, is a tiny sliver of the theoretical burger Venn Diagram.

Now, you could call that grossly mismanaged, or you could call it the best possible shot they had at catering to a wide audience and breaking out of the niche vegan market. But the fact is, the product failed. Where can they possibly go from here to continue growth?


Growth will come when the price comes down. They should be producing this stuff far below the cost of beef.

There’s economies of scale, sure, but the ingredients they use are far cheaper than the inputs required to make beef.

There is effectively no market for this product at costs that exceed beef


> That efficiency comes with time.

And subsidies! Don't forget the subsidies!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: